-
1. They say: City Council would still control borrowing.
The problem: Proposal E says Council “shall authorize” borrowing for the Board. "Shall" means that it legally requires Council to approve the borrowing, even though Council is responsible for protecting the city’s finances. Council needs clear authority to reject debt the city cannot afford. This amendment does not protect that authority.
2. They say: Council would control spending because it approves the budget.
The problem: Approving a budget does not mean approving every decision about how the money is spent. The Board would control utility contracts, property and hiring. Council could approve funding and then oppose what the Board does with it. Budget approval does not give Council control over those decisions.
3. They say: Requiring eight votes to reverse Board decisions adds oversight.
The problem: It makes Council’s oversight harder to use. Ann Arbor has eleven Council members. Even if seven agreed that a Board operational decision was wrong, they could not reverse it. The Board’s decision would stand despite opposition from a clear majority of Council.
4. They say: Other cities have successful utility boards.
The problem: Other cities have different rules. A successful utility in Lansing does not prove that this amendment is well written or that its rules fit Ann Arbor’s Charter. Supporting public power does not require accepting this particular structure. We need clear lines of responsibility for borrowing, spending and hiring here.
5. They say: The Board would cost almost nothing.
The problem: Unpaid Board members still need paid staff support. City employees would organize meetings, prepare documents, draft an ordinance and answer legal and financial questions. Those employees already have work to do. Assigning them more work uses public resources, even if the city does not hire anyone new.
6. They say: The city’s lawyers can handle legal challenges within the existing budget.
The problem: Having lawyers on staff does not make additional lawsuits free. Legal fights take time, and complex cases require specialized work. Time spent defending this amendment is time unavailable for other city business. The fact that the city already handles lawsuits does not establish that its legal staff can absorb more work without added costs or delays elsewhere.
7. They say: Buying and operating costs are irrelevant because this vote does not approve the purchase.
The problem: Voters deserve to understand the cost of the undertaking before creating the board that would run it. Buying DTE’s system would be only the beginning. The utility would need workers, equipment, repairs, billing services and electricity to sell. Those costs belong in the discussion now.
8. They say: An advance deposit is required only if the city seeks a quick takeover.
The problem: The state law they discuss requires a deposit when the city files the court case to take property. Taking possession is a separate step. Avoiding a quick takeover does not remove that filing requirement. Any plan using that law must account for the money needed up front and explain how the city would obtain it.
9. They say: Utility surpluses can replace lost tax revenue.
The problem: A payment to the city does not replace money lost by the schools. Schools, the county, the library system and other public entities need their own replacement revenue. That requires a funded plan showing who gets paid, how much they receive and what those payments add to electric bills. Pointing to surpluses at other utilities does not protect funding for Ann Arbor’s schools.
10. They say: Voters would get another vote before the city buys DTE’s system.
The problem: That vote protects the public’s say over the purchase. It does not fix the rules adopted now. State law requires 60 percent voter approval for the relevant purchase proposal, but that later approval would not rewrite the borrowing language or remove the eight-vote rule. Voters should not put flawed rules into the Charter on the promise of another vote about a different question.
News and Forums:
Councilmember Briggs speaks about why Council opposed Proposal E - NPR, WDET, The Metro- 10/12/26
Environmental Leaders Speak to Why They Oppose Proposal E- Sustainable A2 Roundtable- 10/11/26
Washtenaw County Democratic Party Forum Presentation - July 2026
How Ann Arbor, Michigan is Creating its own Clean Energy Utility- Grist 5/17/26
Background Resources:
City Council Opposing Proposal E, October 2026
2023 Energy Options Analysis, City of Ann Arbor (includes preliminary cost estimates for MEU)
2024 Roadmap to Clean and Equitable Power, University of Michigan Analysis
City of Ann Arbor Sustainable Energy Utility (SEU) - Approved by voters Nov 2024
Join the SEU (planning to move city-wide in 2027)